The Return of the Yogini – Part 2

by Mari P. Ziolkowski, Ph.D.

Yogini - author's image

In the first installment of this paper, we reviewed a sampling of respected academic sources, both Western and Indian.  We looked at sources that named themselves subaltern, as well as spiritual bio/autobiographical sources focused on male saints.  However, in none of these sources was the focus on the role of women as adepts, gurus, or yoginis.  Yet in each source, we found references to the presence of women of power, to yoginis.   I would like to now demonstrate that this was, in fact, only the tip of the iceberg, as Schussler-Fiorenza’s hermeneutics of suspicion would claim. By surveying articles and books specifically focused on the role of women in India, I will demonstrate the return to the Hindu Tantric foreground of the female yogini adept.

Lynn Gatwood, in Devi and the Spouse Goddess, charts the spousification of the independent, sexual tribal goddesses by the Brahminic priestly caste as reflecting the historical effort to ‘domesticate’ the ancient Dravidian peoples, and their wild, untamable goddesses.  When discussing the role of the goddess Kali in left handed Tantra, and the transformation of sexual energy into psychic energy through identification with the male and female aspects of divinity, she states “there are references in the literature to female gurus and initiators.”1

In a book called Oh Terrifying Mother, by Sarah Caldwell, an ethnographer who lived in India for over a year, what could be the history (herstory) of the yogini in South India is discussed.  In describing the tribal roots of low caste possession performances, Caldwell identifies the public religious lives of young women during the 1st to 4th centuries as including festival rites where women would get into a frenzy, dance, sing and participate in possession trances and divination.  She also cites documentation of the existence of female shamans in tribal mountain cultures,2 and goes on to note that female oracles still existed in 1983 in the hilly tribal area of the Palghat region of India, as the last of the female shamanic priests.3

In the book Twilight Goddess by Cleary and Aziz, in the chapter called ‘Tantric Goddess Worship,’ there is a discussion of women suitable for partnership in the Tantric yoni-puja, or worship of the feminine sex.  In noting the ages of women involved–from girl to mature woman, from unmarried to married–and discussing the categories:  dancer/actress, skull wearer, accessible woman, washerwoman, hairdresser, Brahmin, Shudra, cowherd and garland maker’s daughter, there is reference to women of the lower castes not only participating in Tantric rites, but becoming gurus.4 Some of these terms were said to be given to aboriginal tribes of the mountains or forests by Vedic scholars, many of which were matriarchal, matrilineal, or matrilocal, and who, it is thought by many, may be the forebears of Goddess religion and Tantra.5

Specifically, the term ‘skull wearer,’ refers to a “member of the cult of naked or rag-clad ascetics know for such extreme practices as frequenting cemeteries, wearing garlands of bones, and drinking wine from skulls ...” The authors go on to state that “ in spite of their asceticism, these cultists did not believe in seeking a liberation in which there was no pleasure; they concentrated their meditation on the idea of the supreme power resident in the female generative organ, and the men and women of the cult practiced free sexual relations with each other.”6

In further discussion of women involved in Tantric rites, the authors note that one of the categories names “regal, accessible woman,” or woman who is free and independent like a king.”7 There is also mention of the freedom of women from aboriginal tribes, often integrated into society as ‘untouchables,’ the skull bearers who deliberately outcasted themselves, and independent women known as svairini, who had very free attitudes towards sexuality.8 These references certainly indicate the presence of women in tantra, women that could fit the definition of yogini….

In the article “Women in the Saiva and Sakta Ethos,” by Sanjukta Gupta (from Roles and Rituals for Hindu Women), the author discusses women poetess-saints of a specific Tantric tradition, the Saiva, that “were able to subvert their social roles and so achieve self-determination and spiritual fulfillment.”  She states that this is due to the Sakta theology of the Tantras that was “apt to revere women’s spirituality and to respect the autonomy of women saints.”9 She names three saints of this tradition, and states that one of them left home to practice her devotion in the seclusion of the forest, defying genteel society and deliberately choosing the extreme life of a skull bearing ascetic (kapalika) in the wilderness.10

The second woman saint Gupta identifies left her marriage to a king and “discarded everything she possessed, including her clothes, she wandered alone and naked, her long disheveled hair covering her nudity.”  The Saiva group was impressed by her spiritual wisdom and her command of metaphysics, and she was thus accepted into the group of saints….11

The third woman, who due to a difficult relationship with her mother-in-law was turned out of her home, then took up the life of a female tantric renouncer and ascetic practicing yogini.  She followed the ‘left-hand’ tantric tradition, wandering about in a minimum of clothes and used both wine and meat in her religious offerings.  She followed no guru, but her own judgment, and yet, her poetry is found to have sound understanding of the central tenets of Saiva non-dual philosophy.12 She was said to have lived the life of a tantric master, and commanded great respect among the Saivas of Kashmir, and also with the Sufis of that time (all my italics).13 As a Saiva tantric, Gupta states that this poetess Lalla had the option of renouncing social life and following the ways of a … yogini, or even of emulating the stance of the more witch-like dakini …

Kathleen Erndl, in her article “Is Shakti Empowering for Women?” discusses current evidence to suggest that Shakta traditions tend to be more inclusive of women as practitioners, and more accepting of women as leaders or gurus, citing the Shakta influenced Anandamayi Ma, research on Shakta women saints, as well as a study of Shakta women ecstatics.  The author states “in tantric circles, women gurus are commonplace.”14 She documents the work of an artist-activist whose photo exhibits were inspired by a pilgrimage to Kamakhya, “where female and male ascetics perform Tantric practices in caves on the hillsides.”  These exhibitions are excursions “into the lives of “women who dare to define themselves in relations to the metaphysical rather than the social ...”15 And she notes the work of another Indian woman who has established a Tantra Foundation in Delhi “whose aim is not only to preserve Tantric traditions but to promote Tantra as relevant to the lives of contemporary women.”16

In her article “Varieties of Hindu Female Ascetism,” (from Roles and Rituals for Hindu Women) Lynn Denton makes a definitive statement about current tantric ascetism among women in Varanasi, India.   I would like to quote a significant passage from her writing:

Female tantric ascetics may be divided into three groups.  The first consists of female yoga practitioners (yogini):  women who practice yogic postures, breath control and various other ‘acts’ in order to render the body supple, to aid in meditation, to gain a vision of the deity, and to achieve the blissful state of absorption.  The second category consists of women who are called perfected. These women may engage in yogic exercises, but are best known as practitioners of the feared ‘left-hand’ Tantric path ... Female ascetics of this type are free to have sexual relations … perform meditation at night on the cremation ground.  They also seek bliss, but in addition aim to cultivate the psychic of occult power that accompany intense meditative and yogic practice….17

Denton goes on to state:

All female tantric ascetics believe they have very special powers, and none separates the acquisition of power from the notion of spiritual liberation.  Tantric ascetics describe their goal in different ways, emphasizing the state of bliss or madness which it brings.  To be intoxicated and wanton or mad is evidence both of spiritual attainment and of the freedom which their type of asceticism expresses.18

And:

More prevalent among tantric female ascetics as a class (many of whom never perform yoga at all) is their full identification with a deity ...Those who do not act as oracles none the less consider themselves to be the embodiment of a deity … Tantrics believe (and act as if) they are already divine.19

In case the reader is not yet convinced of the presence of female adepts in the Tantric tradition, let me present further evidence.  In Yogini Cult and Temples, the author (Vidya Dehejia) touches on a critical issue almost immediately in the preface: though the tantric scriptures are almost written in code, it is there that one can find the most information on the yogini tradition.20 She sources her work on Indian manuscript libraries she personally visited.21

Though Dehijia’s work mainly focuses on non-human yoginis of the temples, those who are considered patron goddesses of the Kaulika Tantrics, however, in her introduction, she discusses the different meanings of the word yogini–three of which fit our purposes: a female devotee, a sorceress/witch, and a yogic adept who acquires magical powers.22 Regarding the existence of yoginis as followers and adepts in yoga, Dehijia references paintings, where they are often portrayed as ascetic mendicants or seated in shrines visited by male and female devotees.23 Magical powers of these yoginis are cited as breath control, levitation, and control over living creatures. Regarding their independent status, the author documents no fixed place of residence for these yoginis, stating they wander the country-side acquiring followers and teaching them difficult path of yoga.24

Regarding the sorceress and yogic adept, the author documents through various stories the specific powers of yoginis, dakinis, and sakinis, to include the following:  power to shapeshift, power to fly through the air, power to resurrect the dead, power to become small, power to become gigantic, the power of compelling will, control over body and mind, control of the elements, and fulfillment of all one’s desires (let alone other more controversial powers)….25 The author also discusses the very Tantric-sounding practices of gathering in cemeteries, sacrificing of animals, eating of flesh and the corpse ritual (offering of wine, ritual breathing and sexual union on top of a body) as methods for gaining these magical powers.26 Later she specifically documents some of these sorceresses as following the unorthodox path of the Kapalika Tantrics.27

Dehijia also documents yogini practitioners in the Tantric tradition known as the Kaula Marga path, specifically discussing their role in aspects of the maithuna (sacred sexual) rite.28 She describes them as utilizing sexuality as a way of liberation--including circle practice in the yogini temples.  In the circle, a yogini is paired up with an unknown partner.  Anointing of the body and touching is emphasized.  All women in the circle are the Devi and all men Shiva. The human female yogini, representing the goddess, receives the yogi as a representative of Shiva.29 Kularnava Tantra mentions the female partners of the Ritual as yoginis as well, documents Dehijia.30 And in Kamkhya these women adepts are known as Bhairavis.31

Dehijia gives indicators of the position of esteem in which the yoginis are held on this path.  Things that will anger the yoginis are listed as the following: insulting a woman, striking a woman, speaking of her faults, being angry with a woman, and making caste distinctions.32 Again regarding the independent status of these women adepts, the author notes that the yoginis of the Kaula Tantric path do not live with any yogi on a permanent basis, but are called upon for ritual on holy days … And states that there are yoginis currently practicing the Kaula Cakra Ritual.….33 (all my italics)

Several authors have tantalized us with documentation of yoginis not only in the Tantric history of India, but their presence today (Svodboda, Caldwell, Denton).  What about the following two sources? Daniel Odier’s 1996 account of his long term studies in Buddhism, Hinduism and Tantra, his long search for a guru, and his initiation into the sacred sexual practice of the Kashmir Shaivic tradition by a female tantrika, chronicled in Tantric Quest? And Amarananda Bhairavan’s spiritual autobiography documenting his childhood initiation in East India, in a village where “the matriarchies gave prime recognition to women in spiritual and temporal matters,” where “women seers and tantrikas enjoyed superior standing compared to their male counterparts,”34 where in fact he tells the story of his initiation by a female preceptor/sorceress (his aunt), and a local village female aghori (magical practitioner)?  Where he discusses the female vallipachads (holy women) and healers throughout the story?  Where his female cousin is initiated with him?  This man was in residence at the Kali Temple of Dakshineswar in Laguna Beach, California (2002).  His account was published in 2000 and provides more current evidence for female yoginis, sorcerers and aghoris practicing the Tantric path….

So what do we ultimately have here?  What exactly have we uncovered?  What have we teased out of accepted academic sources, rather subaltern sources, depictions of saint’s lives, personal lives, woman centered sources, sources from undiscovered manuscripts of ancient India and current spiritual autobiographies?  Have we discovered the presence of the female adept, sorcerer, magician, yogini that has been there all along in the history of India?  Hidden from view but now rising to the surface, out of the shadows, to take her rightful place in the Goddess worshipping traditions of India?  You decide …

Part 1 of The Return of the Yogini appeared in Goddess Pages Issue 23 (Summer 2013)

 

Notes

1 Lynn Gatwood, Devi and the Spouse Goddess (Maryland: Riverdale, 1985): 162-3.

2 Sara Caldwell, Oh Terrifying Mother (1999): 24.

3 Ibid., 25.

4 Cleary and Aziz, The Twilight Goddess (Boston and London: Shambhala, 2000): 30.

5 Ibid., 31.

6 Ibid.

7 Ibid., 32.

8 Ibid., 36-7.

9 Sanjukta Gupta, “Women in the Saiva and Sakta Ethos,” in Julie Leslie’s Roles and Ritual for Hindu Women (1991):195.

10 Ibid., 197-8.

11 Ibid., 198-9.

12 Ibid., 199-200.

13 Ibid., 201.

14 Kathleen Erndl, “Is Shakti Empowering for Women?” Is The Goddess A Feminist? (New York: New York University Press, 2000): 93.

15 Ibid., 99.

16 Ibid., 94.

17 Lynn Denton, “Varieties of Hindu Female Asceticism, “ Julie Leslie’s Roles and Rituals for Hindu Women (Rutherford, Madison, Teaneck: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1991): 226.

18 Ibid., 227.

19 Ibid., 229.

20 Dehejia, xi.

21 Ibid., x.

22 Ibid., 11-12.

23 Ibid., 11.

24 Ibid.

25 Ibid., 13-15, 53.

26 Ibid., 15.

27 Ibid., 17.

28 Ibid., 11.

29 Ibid., 13, 62-3.

30 Ibid., 32.

31 Ibid., 63.

32 Ibid., 34.

33 Ibid., 63.

34 Amarananda Bhairavan, Kali’s Odiyya (Maine: Nicolas Hays, 2000): xi.

Bibliography

Bhairavan, Amarananda (2000) Kali’s Odiyya, Maine: Nicolas Hays
Bhattacharya, Brajamadhava (1988)The World of Tantra, New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharial
Bhattacharyya, Narendra Nath (1996) History of the Sakta Religion, New Delhi:   Munshiram Manoharial Publishers
Cleary & Aziz, (2000) Twilight Goddess, Boston and London: Shambhala
Dehijia, Vidya (1986) Yogini Cult and Temples, New Delhi: National Museum
Denton, Lynn, “Varieties of Hindu Female Asceticism” from Roles and Rituals for Hindu Women (ed. Julia Leslie) Rutherford/Madison/Teaneck: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
Dyczkowski, Mark (1987) The Doctrine of Vibration, State University of New York Press
Erndl, Kathleen, “Is Shakti Empowering for Women?” in Is the Goddess a Feminist? (2000) New York: New York University Press
Gatwood, Lynn, (1985) Devi and the Spouse Goddess, Maryland: Riverdale
Gupta, Sanjukta (1991) “Women in the Saiva/Sakta Ethos” in Roles and Rituals for Hindu Women (ed. Julia Leslie) Rutherford/Madison/Teaneck: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
Gupta, Hoens, Goudriaan, (1979) Hindu Tantrism, Leiden/Koln: Brill
Harding, Elizabeth (1993) Kali: The Black Goddess of Dakshineswar, Maine: Nicolas Hays
Jordan, Donna (1999) A Post Orientalist History of the Fierce Sakti of the SubAltern Domain, CIIS Dissertation
Nikhilananda, Swami, trans.(1973) The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna, New York: Ramakrishna;Vivekananda Center
Odier, Daniel, (1996) Tantric Quest, Vermont: Inner Traditions
Shaw, Miranda (1994) Passionate Enlightenment: Women in Tantric Buddhism, New Jersey: Princeton University Press
Silburn, Lilian, (1988) Kundalini: The Energy of the Depths, State University of New York Press
Svoboda, Robert (1986) Aghora: At the Left Hand of God, Washington: Sadhana Publications

 

Mari P Ziolkowski PhD

In the interest of healing self, others and the planet, Mari has been following the call of earth based/divine female energies for 20 years. Drawn to walk a heart path in the midstof the beauty and paradox of the earth plane, Mari continues to be engaged by the personal and planetary need to rebalance the feminine and masculine energies. Find out more about her work at: www.spiritmaa.webs.com

Latest posts by Mari P Ziolkowski PhD (see all)